Your Thursday Beery News Notes For That Final If Quite Expected Killing Frost

Well, it had to come eventually. Most of the tomato vines were hit by frost Monday at dawn. It’s OK. I know you join me in thanking them for a productive season. And we are pretty much eight weeks from the seed catelogue orders going out so it’s all a bit of a circle. Seasons turn.

Speaking of which, we are now closing in on the end of the year so the “best of” pronouncements have been appearing. The hackles of Boak and Bailey were ever so slightly lifted by one recent guide to London’s pubs published by Vittles* and ATJ announced his forthcoming guide to 80 pubs around England and Wales being included in the Daily Star.   Phil Mellows questioned very the idea itself: “… there is, of course, no such thing as 60 ‘best pubs’…” preferring instead to point you in the direction of the 2027 edition the Good Beer Guide. One is left with questions. Like… what even is real? OK, fine. Maybe not that question.

Relatedly perhaps, Knut wrote this week on the history of the brewing trade’s association in Norway, aka the Bryggeri- og Drikkevareforeningen… I think… on the occassion of its 125th anniversary. And he made a rather pointed point about the genesis of the organization:

The Norwegian Brewers Association was founded in November 1901 through the merger of two predecessor organizations: the Christiania Brewers Association, established in 1893, and the Norwegian Brewers Association, founded in 1894. One might think that these representatives of free enterprise joined forces to promote healthy competition. In reality, they probably lived up rather well to Adam Smith’s observation that people of the same trade seldom meet together without the conversation ending in some contrivance against the public, or in some plan to raise prices. As early as 1902 they agreed on a common pricing arrangement. Work soon began on dividing market shares across different regions of the country. 

And, as noted by Jeff, we see similar sorts of machinations today with the Brewers Association in the USA which made an extraordinary pronouncement:

…nobody cares whether there’s a brewhouse on the other side of the taproom wall. Once that was a huge issue in the industry, and brewery-less beer companies carried the scent of scandal. Today, the average drinker has no idea where the beer is made, nor do they care. Matt emphasizes this point: “If the thing customers value most isn’t your production facility, the cost of owning and operating that brewhouse may not be central to meeting their needs. There are signs that customers have become more accustomed to drinking beer somewhere other than where it’s produced. Just look to all of the satellite taprooms that have popped up separate from production facilities.”

What a statement about the quality of the organization’s twenty plus years of public education efforts. I would suggest that “nobody” here might mean folk who don’t care that much about beer.  Which apparently includes much of their membership.  Which means the transformation away from the association of small, traditional and independent brewers is complete. They accepted the large, they ditched traditional practices and embraced selling out years ago. Now they have recommended not even brewing yourself. There’s a word for a taproom run by a firm that has its beer brewed by another. A bar.

No doubt thankful to be elsewhere, Ron has reported back from his trip to Arequipa in southern Peru care of the Arequipa tourist board where he stood in judgement. Or probably sat. He has posted one,  two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight reports on the experience so there’s a lot of detail in there for you who are planning on emulating that jet-set lifestyle. Upon his return, Ron reflected on this part of his life, quite charmlingly:

Every trip knocks weeks off my work time. Before I go, I have to write up blog posts to cover the time I’ll be away. And queue up a few YouTube videos. That takes the best part of a week. When I return, another week goes writing the travel blog posts that no-one reads. I was thinking about all this earlier. Sitting on the side of a canal reading Viz,  the setting sun glints of the water in an explosion of dancing sparks, the tress on the opposite bank wave. Crows craw and moorhen peck at the grass. I could be in the countryside. If it weren’t for the white traffic noise from the motorway and the buzzing of scooter.

I read them, Ron, and the rest of you folk around here abouts should too. That day trip out across the desert is a classic.

Like some of Ron thoughts on a few of the submissions placed before him at the judges’ table there in Peru, The Beer Nut has shared a disappointment:

It smells pithy, which is not a typical haze attribute, and the flavour is small and uncomplicated. I guess that’s what they mean by “mellow” but it’s quite a euphemism. The pith remains the main thing to taste, even though it’s barely present. That tang also suggests soluble vitamin tablets and sugar-free orangeade. Looking closely, I found an even slighter note of citrus fruit flesh, but that’s very brief. The finish includes an unpleasant hot gritty dreg element which makes me feel hard done by, given how low-key the haze look and flavour are. Lacklustre, is the word for this. It’s not often that I have a problem with a Sierra Nevada pale ale, but this one has had all the goodness compromised out of it.

Hot gritty dreg!* One wonders who that sort of beer is created for. People who don’t care? Maybe there’s a ripple in the continuum that brewers have yet to figure out. BMI reports on one cultural change that may be in the mix:

Declines in binge drinking are among the clearest and most impactful changes in alcohol consumption in recent years, our analysis of major national surveys suggests. The prevalence of recent heavy drinking occasions declined considerably in just the last few years, especially among younger legal age and underage drinkers. Further, a reduction in the self-reported frequency of past-month binges suggests that a sizable chunk of total alcohol volume lost in recent years can be attributed to declines in drinking patterns most likely to be considered harmful.

[Ed.: “Has there been a corresponding drop in donair sales in Halifax?“] That decline in binge drinking is interesting because it would explain how it is possible for trade PR writers to exclaim “young people still drink!” while raw trade statistics continue year after year to trace a significant drop in alcohol consumption. Or perhaps kids today are just concerned for their kidneys. The Telegraph reported this past Tuesday on a UK medical study (one that seems to have been released back on October 20th) which suggests that beer is especially not the kidney’s pal:

After adjustment for covariables and/or potential confounders in Cox proportional hazard regression analyses, spirits (HR, 1.40; 95% CI, 1.30 to 1.50) and beer (HR, 1.24; 95% CI, 1.17 to 1.32) consumption were associated with AKI, while associations were absent for red wine (HR, 0.96; 95% CI, 0.90 to 1.02) and white wine (HR, 1.06; 95% CI, 0.98 to 1.14).

Sure, I know we can all debate the applicability of the old Cox proportional hazard regression analyses but I think we can also agree not to frig with matters renal. Or cardiac for that matter as a separate study reported upon this week found:

Moderate wine drinkers had a 21% lower risk of dying from cardiovascular disease than people who never or only occasionally drank alcohol. By comparison, even low consumption of beer, cider, or spirits was associated with a 9% higher risk of cardiovascular death.

I would place those two medical matters in the basket labeled “Bad News for Beer” myself. And, speaking of medical reports, Charlotte Cook, brewer and writer herself, received an odd request this week and wrote about her reaction:

As a “trusted voice” in the alcohol scene I can point you in the direction of a good pub with nice beer. If you’re a brewer with a problem in your brewery I can help you troubleshoot. I cannot help someone toward the right treatment if they’re concerned about their use of alcohol, and even though that £100 might come in very handy, I cannot accept money or push a programme where I can’t even read the study the treatment is based on. I have long been deeply sceptical of influencer culture, and I find the concept of being given money to promote medical intervention deeply troubling. Not only have I not used the programme, or the drugs, I have no understanding of any side effects or the provision of or requirement for robust psychological support for someone facing substance abuse issues.

What a weird suggestion. And for a measly £100! Not sure I’d get out of bed for that let alone stake my reputation on a blind affirmation like that. Still… do they pay up front?

Speaking of bad news for beer, Rachel Auty of Women on Tap, an organization promoting gender equity in the beer industry, shared the findings of a survey on the gender inclusivity in the UK beer scene which found 57% of women responding said the beer industry is not very accessible for women while only 13% of men agreed:

…research tells us men and women are looking at the same industry and seeing very different things. We can also see that there’s a belief the main issues are outside of one’s own sphere of influence. These two things could well be a big part of why change is just not happening in beer. Breweries also told us they want practical, ready-to-use help, and that is exactly what we’re building. The research presents a valuable indicative pulse check and there are some clear themes we will now address and build on.

As we consider again the solitudes in brewing, here’s some notes:

Note #1: Are pubs for good vibes or good beer?**
Note #2: Irv’s Basement Bar. Irv is 102.
Note #3: Molson recalls a range of Canadian brands.
Note #4: what is “a Spanish beer and lifestyle research organization”?

Acting as my own beer and lifestyle research organization, I wrote about the very likeable Fuller’s Vintage Ale 2026. So did Nigel. I was at the limit of my price point with that one, though if one can trust (as one surely can!) Mr. Protz my $10.95 CND paid for a bottle is just 68% of the price of £8.50 one is charged for the same beer in the UK.*** On an even more extreme situation and for the double, The Beer Nut is made of stronger stuff, methinks:

Haven’t seen Bourbon County in these parts in many a year. Although at those prices, they can stay on the shelf.

At 21€, those BC19 bottles were three times the price of my VA26 bottle! I guess the tradition of sucker juice lives on, perhaps only in brewery marketeering circles.

More tough news, this time out of Maryland as Heavy Seas owner Harry Sissons announces he is to retire as his brewery has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection:

Heavy Seas has faced growing financial pressures amid changing customer preferences and generational shifts away from alcohol. Court documents show its parent company, Clipper City Brewing Company, has more than $4.3 million in debt… “I’m not going to renew the lease, because that doesn’t make any sense,” Sisson said. “So, I decided that the thing to do was to find a way to license the production of my brands somewhere else, turn that into an income stream.” Sisson acknowledged that selling all of his brewing equipment could be a challenge, as breweries across the country face shrinking revenues. In the 1980s, Sisson helped pass legislation legalizing brewpubs in Maryland. Now, after decades in the brewing industry, he says he is ready to retire.

Definitely beers I would grab on the stash filling road trips south of yore. So you can’t blame me all on me for not ordering that Loose Cannon back in 2012 or the next day at Max’s no neither no way.

Conversely with a glimmer of hope, there was possibly some good news for the troubled hop industry from an unexpected source:

Procter & Gamble is about to roll out what it says is the biggest innovation in toothpaste since stabilized stannous fluoride: a hops extract added to its Crest line that reduces gum bleeding by breaking up biofilms on teeth. The chemicals behind that big claim are β-acids, a mix of closely related molecules extracted from the same types of hops that are used in beer. P&G unveiled the ingredient at a 2-day event in Cincinnati this week attended by dentists, periodontists, and dental hygienists.

I will defer to Stan who knows so much about hops AND has suspiciously  sparkling bicuspids – but I found the idea that brewers would somehow also elbow their way into the innovation’s supply chain odd. Surely all that beta acid’s goodness should be left in the beer but, who knows, maybe the cost of gathering and processing trub could be cheaper than just buying the raw hops from the grower.

And finally, for Pellicle Fred Garratt-Stanley explored the role that wood plays in setting the tone… perhaps the vibe… in the English pub:

If there’s one thing that virtually all great British pubs have in common—from ancient inns like The George in Norton St Philip to ornate urban gin palaces like The Vines in Liverpool and austere, interwar boozers like the Rose & Crown in Oxford—it’s wood.  In my view, there’s a direct correlation between how timber-heavy a pub interior is and how appealing the space is to the drinker. Wood is not just functional. Its materiality evokes a deeper sense of security, a welcoming warmth, a feeling of being part of something much older than you. Wooden beams or panelling might not be the first features that punters consciously register upon entering a pub. But they will certainly feel their impact—or their absence—on its atmosphere.

Wood is good. But as the story unfolds, it may be a tale of the faux of some time ago or an echo of some place beyond the immediate and urban.

There. That is it for another week. Coming up? False aka American Thanksgiving. Expect to be informed in the interim on what beer goes with turkey. As you consider that, please also check out Boak and Bailey’s postings on each and every Saturday along with their fabulously entertaining footnotes week after week at Patreon. And do look out for more of Stan’s “One Link, One Paragraph” format. Then it’s your turn. Read and recommend, please. Scour the world for news tips – then let me know. Then hunt out something in someone’s archives! Leave oblique comments on someone’s post from 2009!! I just got spammed on a 2005 post myself! Listen to a few of Lew’s podcasts and get your emailed issue of Episodes of my Pub Life by David Jesudason on certain Fridays. And Phil Mellows is at the BritishBeerBreaks. Once a month, Will Hawkes issues his London Beer City newsletter and promises his own best pubs guide. Do sign up for Katie’s wonderful self-governing totes autonomous website featuring The Gulp, too.  Ben’s Beer and Badword remains on pause but there is reading at The Glass which is going back to being a blog. Any more? We have Ontario’s own A Quick Beer and All About Beer is still offering a range of podcasts – and there’s also Mike Seay’s The Perfect Pour. Plus follow the venerable Full Pint podcast! And there’s the Craft Beer Channel on Youtube as well as the archives of the Beer Ladies Podcast. What else?

*I had their third album.
**I’m team vibe. I’ll choke back any old crap if the bar is good.
***On Nov 17th, one UK pound was worth $1.89 CND according to the internets meaning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *